When it comes to buying the right power tools for the right job, getting what you need for a quality job without breaking the bank can be tricky. You have many options to choose from across the board, but with this guide, you’ll learn the pros and cons of two leading brands: Black & Decker and DeWalt.
Black & Decker is excellent if you want to spend less, and you’re looking for tools for personal use to finish a home repair. However, if you’re a professional hired for a project for another client, you’ll want to spend extra money on the better quality and reliability of DeWalt power tools.
This article will contrast the differences in what both of these brands do, how they’re built, and why there’s an intentional difference in cost. I’ll also determine which one is best suited for your projects, demands, and basic needs. If you’ve seen these brands in stores and always wanted to know which is better to buy, keep reading.
Black & Decker Pros and Cons
Black & Decker products are great if you need them for occasional use or personal projects. They’re designed for beginners and entry-level work and cost less than higher-end power tool brands, including DeWalt.
The downside is that a lower cost for the tools means lower production value for the product. Black & Decker tools don’t have the same build and quality as higher-end brands and are not expected to last as long for use. Warranties on Black & Decker power tools are also shorter (at around two years), and the contract is voided if you use the device in any manner aside from home use.
Why Are Black & Decker Power Tools Lower Quality?
Black & Decker power tools are lower quality and more cost-effective because they’re for entry-level customers. Keeping the manufacturing process cheaper allows the company to keep the price of the products more affordable for people that only need them for shorter-term use.
Black & Decker Products
Black & Decker sells a large variety of products, some of which you’ve probably seen in stores or online. Some of the products Black & Decker sells are:
Are Black & Decker Products Good?
Black & Decker products are good. Black & Decker products are excellent for personal use and home repair, as they’re decently priced, and therefore, more affordable for the average person. Although Black & Decker products are not for industrial use, they’re excellent personal tools.
Are Black & Decker Products a Waste of Money if They Don’t Last Long?
Black & Decker Products are not a waste of money even though they don’t last long. Black & Decker is still a viable choice for hobbyists and personal projects around the house. The lower price and quality of the products don’t invalidate buying them, they’re just not meant for industrial use.
DeWalt Pros and Cons
DeWalt products are perfect for working professionals needing tools for long-term use and heavy-duty applications. They’re designed for experts and serious projects instead of novices and occasional fixes.
The quality of DeWalt power tools is much higher and longer-lasting with stronger batteries and more powerful motors. You can use DeWalt products at home, but they’re much more suited for worksites and made from more quality materials for durability.
The downside of DeWalt tools is that they’re more expensive because of the cost of higher quality, and the build of the products passes down to the buyer. DeWalt tools will last longer and avoid rust and repairs much better, but they’re not cost-effective for entry-level workers or carpenters.
The Reason DeWalt Is More Expensive
DeWalt products are owned by Stanley Black & Decker group, the same as Black & Decker products are. DeWalt is marketed and made as a more expensive line of tools for a higher grade of work and a more serious worker that needs durability and quality for their jobs.
Additionally, DeWalt tools have a more extended three-year warranty, and there are fewer restrictions on what kinds of projects you can use the tools to complete. The idea is that DeWalt is priced out from entry-level buyers because they don’t need to buy them. Experienced professionals can and should be able to afford them.
Am I Spending Too Much if I Buy DeWalt for Home Use?
You are spending too much if you buy DeWalt for home use. DeWalt is made specifically for industrial and professional use. So, unless you plan on using tools in your home more often than usual or just want higher quality, there’s no need to spend a large sum of money on this brand.
DeWalt sells a large variety of products, ranging from hand tools to outdoor accessories. Here is a list of products DeWalt sells includes:
You have many more options with DeWalt tools than you will with Black & Decker and other brands that are more entry-level in general.
Is DeWalt the Best Choice for Professional Work?
DeWalt is not the best choice for professional work. Although DeWalt has a more substantial build quality and better warranty than Black & Decker, there are many other higher-end brands of power tools that serious workers can look at to suit their needs.
Why Black & Decker Owns DeWalt
Black & Decker started in 1910 intending to make the world’s first portable power tool and built its brand and products with that belief in mind over the next 40 years. It soon became one of the leading makers of power tools and accessories in the United States.
DeWalt was formed in 1923 and took off with the invention of the radial saw. The company primarily made power tools for the woodworking, construction, and manufacturing industries. It was bought by Black & Decker in 1960 and began selling hand tools and mechanic’s tools in the early 2010s.
Black & Decker also owns:
Among all of its brands, Black & Decker is at the lowest end of consumer brand positioning because it caters to a cheaper customer, while DeWalt is at the upper end because it targets industry professionals.
The Price Comparison: Black & Decker vs. DeWalt
Black & Decker tools range from $25 for a 3.6-Volt Lithium-Ion Cordless Rechargeable Screwdriver with Charger to $179 for 20-Volt Max Lithium-Ion Cordless Matrix Drill Combo Kits complete with storage case.
DeWalt tools range from $32 for a Demolition Hammer to $4733 for a 20-Volt MAX Cordless Dieless Cable Crimping Tool, complete with two 20-Volt 4.0Ah Batteries, Charger, Case, and Cable Cutting Tool.
When comparing similar items like cordless drills, Black & Decker sells a 20-Volt MAX Lithium-Ion Cordless Drill and Project Kit with Battery 1.5Ah, Charger, and Kit Bag for $89. At the same time, DeWalt offers multiple 20-Volt MAX cordless drill sets from $99 to $279.
Black & Decker and DeWalt sell similar power tools and products. Still, while Black & Decker is for beginners, DeWalt is for professional workers, which means direct comparison between the two isn’t so clear-cut at the end of the day.
If you want power tools that get the job done around the house, Black & Decker is the better, more cost-effective option for you.
However, if you’re a contractor or some other professional construction worker that needs reliable tools that can take a beating on big and heavy professional projects, you should go with DeWalt.